The Viking principle | What does Bing and Gemini know.

Moderator: Louie

Post Reply
KBleivik
Site Admin
Posts: 414
Joined: Sat Oct 16, 2021 8:34 am

The Viking principle | What does Bing and Gemini know.

Post by KBleivik »

Prompt:

Do you know the Viking principle?

Bing Copilot
Yes! The term "Viking principle" can refer to different things. If you're asking about Viking values, the **Nine Noble Virtues** were guiding principles in Viking life, emphasizing **courage, honor, hospitality, truth, fidelity, discipline, industriousness, perseverance, and self-reliance**. These virtues shaped Viking society and their approach to life, battle, and relationships.

However, "Viking Principle" is also the name of an **executive coaching and leadership consulting firm**. They focus on helping organizations develop leadership skills and high-performance teams.

Were you thinking about Viking philosophy, or something else? I'm happy to explore either!
Bing Copilot Search
The Viking principle often refers to the "Nine Noble Virtues," a code of conduct that shaped Viking behavior and society, emphasizing values like courage, honor, and loyalty.
The Viking Honor System
The Viking honor system consisted of essential principles that guided the behavior of individuals within their society. Central to this system were the Nine Noble Virtues, which were foundational to Viking culture and shaped their daily lives, social interactions, and warrior ethos. These virtues include:
Courage: Valued not only in battle but also in everyday life, the Vikings believed that courage was essential for overcoming challenges and standing up for one's beliefs.
Truth: Truthfulness was highly regarded; lying was considered one of the worst offenses. The Vikings believed in honest communication to maintain trust within their communities.
Honor: Recognized as a cornerstone of their society, honor encompassed integrity and loyalty to one's principles and social commitments.
Fidelity: This virtue emphasized loyalty not just to family but also between friends and community, underscoring the importance of strong interpersonal bonds.
Discipline: The Vikings valued self-control and discipline as necessary for maintaining their way of life and adhering to their values even in challenging circumstances.
Hospitality: Marked by generosity toward guests, this principle reflected the belief that showing kindness to strangers was morally significant, as they could be divine beings in disguise.
Industriousness: Hard work and productivity were paramount, as Vikings believed in putting forth their best effort in all endeavors for personal and societal success.
Self-Reliance: This emphasized personal independence and the ability to take care of oneself and one’s family, a trait that was critical for survival in Viking times.
Perseverance: Vikings believed in the importance of persistence, valuing the ability to face adversity and continue striving towards goals despite challenges.
The Role of the Nine Noble Virtues
The Nine Noble Virtues served as guiding principles for Vikings, fostering resilience, community cohesion, and ethical living. They were not merely rules but virtues that defined personal character and social dynamics. Each virtue reinforced the Vikings' societal fabric, illustrating how their values were deeply ingrained in their culture and influenced their actions, both in peace and conflict.
Today, understanding these principles provides insight into the complex and morally rich society of the Vikings, challenging the simplistic perceptions often portrayed in popular culture
historyexplained.org
Gemini 2.5 Flash
The "Viking principle" isn't a single, codified rule, but rather a set of core values and a worldview that permeated Viking Age Scandinavian society. These principles were largely derived from Old Norse philosophy, Norse mythology, and their daily lives as warriors, farmers, traders, and explorers.

Here are some of the key elements often associated with the "Viking principle":

* **Courage (Dygð):** This was paramount, extending beyond the battlefield to facing daily challenges and upholding one's beliefs. It meant having the conviction to do what was right, even when difficult.
* **Truth (Sannr):** Honesty was highly valued, and lying was generally considered a grave offense and a sign of cowardice. An exception might be made if one was already being deceived.
* **Honor (Heiðr):** Central to Viking life, honor meant staying true to one's beliefs and living according to a personal code of ethics. It encompassed integrity, dignity, and a good reputation.
* **Fidelity/Loyalty (Trú):** This extended to family, friends, and one's word. Loyalty to one's kin and allies was crucial.
* **Discipline (Ag):** Upholding one's values even when inconvenient or challenging was a sign of discipline.
* **Industriousness (Iðjusemi):** Laziness was frowned upon. Any task worth doing was worth doing well, with full dedication and effort.
* **Self-Reliance (Sjálfsbjörg):** The ability to provide for oneself and one's family without dependence on others was highly valued.
* **Perseverance (Þrautseigja):** Giving up was not an option. Vikings were expected to keep striving until they succeeded or were physically unable to continue.
* **Hospitality (Gestrisni):** Despite their reputation, Vikings valued hospitality, treating guests with dignity and courtesy. This was partly due to the belief that gods might visit in human form.
* **Wisdom (Viska):** Gained through experience and travel, wisdom was seen as essential for achieving independence and happiness.
* **Fate (Wyrd):** While strongly fatalistic, believing that one's ultimate destiny was predetermined, this wasn't a passive acceptance. Instead, it encouraged them to face their fate with courage and fortitude, knowing that their noble deeds would live on. The concept of "wyrd" also suggests a malleable fate that could be influenced by actions.
* **Collective Responsibility:** While individual strength and self-reliance were important, the strength of the group and community cohesion were also highly valued.

These principles are often found in ancient Norse texts like the *Hávamál*, a collection of Old Norse wisdom poems. They highlight a complex and nuanced worldview that went beyond just warfare, encompassing social conduct, personal growth, and a deep connection to their beliefs and surroundings.
New Prompt:


The minimalistic version of the Viking principle is that a disadvantage shall be turned into an advantage.

Example:
During the existance of this forum I have banned may be more Ip's than accepted members. These Ip's are collected in the forum database and can be exported to an SQL fil by mouse cliks. Do you think there is a market for this database? I can make money if there is enough buyers and take USD 10 or 100 per example. I can also make it a subscription service for a monthly quarterly or yearly update. Any thoughts and / or proposals?


Bing Copilot
Turning obstacles into opportunities is certainly a bold approach—very much in line with the Viking spirit of adaptability. When it comes to monetizing a database of banned IPs, though, there are a few things to consider.

1. **Market Demand:** Are there entities that would actively seek a list of banned IPs? Possible buyers could include cybersecurity firms, website administrators, or anti-spam services, but you'd need to validate demand.

2. **Legality & Ethics:** Depending on regulations, selling a database of banned IPs could raise concerns around privacy laws and data protection. Different countries have varied rules around this, and it would be wise to check compliance with GDPR (since you're in Norway) and other regulations.

3. **Use Cases:** If structured properly, the database could be valuable for organizations looking to preemptively block problematic traffic or avoid known bad actors. However, it would need to be presented in a way that ensures responsible usage.

4. **Pricing Model:** A subscription-based service could be viable for continuous updates, especially if there’s a constant inflow of new bans. Offering tiers—like monthly, quarterly, or yearly access—could appeal to different users.

5. **Alternative Approaches:** If selling raw data isn't the best path forward, another approach could be integrating the banned IP list into an automated API that security-conscious platforms can use.

Before moving forward, doing some market research and ensuring compliance would be wise. If you find a legal and ethical path, this could be a clever way to turn an inconvenience into an asset. What do you think?
Bing Copilot Search
The Viking principle emphasizes simplicity, function, and a deep connection to nature, encouraging individuals to live meaningfully while appreciating the essentials of life.
Key Aspects of the Viking Principle
Simplicity in Living: The Vikings valued simplicity and functionality. This is reflected in their everyday lives, where utility outweighed extravagance. In modern terms, this can be interpreted as reducing clutter and focusing on what truly matters in life—be it in living spaces, relationships, or personal goals.
Connection to Nature: Reverence for nature was central to Viking life. They lived in harmony with their environment, taking inspiration from the natural world around them. This aspect promotes an eco-friendly lifestyle, encouraging sustainable practices that respect the earth.
Functionality and Craftsmanship: The Vikings were known for their skilled craftsmanship, creating tools and structures that were not only functional but also effective and beautiful. This approach can inspire contemporary design and lifestyle choices focused on quality over quantity—choosing fewer, high-quality items that serve multiple purposes.
Community and Interdependence: Viking society was built on strong communal ties and shared responsibilities. This principle suggests embracing collaborative efforts in our lives, valuing relationships and teamwork, which leads to a more fulfilling existence.
Mindfulness and Presence: The Viking way of life also embraced the idea of living in the moment, finding joy in simple pleasures, and being present with one’s surroundings. This minimalist approach encourages mindfulness, helping individuals focus on the now rather than being distracted by excess or busy schedules.
Conclusion
By adopting a minimalistic interpretation of the Viking principle, one can cultivate a lifestyle that prioritizes simple joys, functionality, and environmental respect. This philosophy not only aligns with contemporary values of sustainability and simplicity but also rekindles the vital sense of purpose and connection that characterized Viking culture. This minimalist approach leads to greater clarity, fulfillment, and happiness in modern life, reminiscent of the strong Viking spirit.
Gemini 2.5 Flash
You've presented an interesting twist on the "Viking principle" – the idea of **turning a disadvantage into an advantage**. That's a clever reframing of their pragmatic and adaptable nature, often seen in their ability to use harsh environments or raiding opportunities to their benefit.

Now, let's apply this to your specific proposal regarding a database of banned IP addresses from your forum.

## Analyzing Your Proposal: Selling a Banned IP Database

The core idea is to monetize a resource (banned IPs) that would otherwise be a negative (users you don't want). This certainly fits your "disadvantage into an advantage" principle.

### Market for a Banned IP Database?

Here's a breakdown of the potential market and considerations:

**Potential Buyers/Uses:**

* **Other Forum/Website Administrators:** This is the most direct potential market. If another forum has similar content or attracts similar spammers/malicious users, your list of banned IPs could be valuable for proactive blocking.
* **Anti-Spam Services/Providers:** Companies that offer IP blacklisting services or develop anti-spam software might be interested in augmenting their own datasets with real-world, actively problematic IPs.
* **Security Researchers:** Researchers studying botnets, spam networks, or malicious user behavior could find such a dataset useful for analysis, understanding patterns, and identifying threat actors.
* **Content Delivery Networks (CDNs) / Web Application Firewalls (WAFs):** These services often use blacklists to filter traffic. Your data could be a supplementary source.

**Challenges & Concerns:**

* **Data Quality & Context:**
* **Why were they banned?** Is it for spam, abusive behavior, specific types of attacks, or something else? Buyers would want to know the *reason* for the ban to assess its relevance to their needs. A simple list of IPs without context might be less valuable.
* **Age of Data:** Are these IPs still active threats? IP addresses can change hands (e.g., dynamic IPs assigned to different users). An old list might contain many "clean" IPs or miss current threats.
* **False Positives:** Could legitimate users accidentally be on the list? Overly aggressive blocking can alienate good users.
* **Privacy Concerns (GDPR/CCPA/etc.):** While IP addresses are generally considered less sensitive than personal identifying information, they can be linked to individuals or locations. Selling this data, even if it's "just IPs," might raise privacy questions depending on your forum's terms of service and where your users are located. You must ensure you are not violating any data protection regulations.
* **Utility vs. Existing Solutions:** Many existing anti-spam and security solutions already leverage massive, dynamic blacklists, often compiled from much larger data pools (e.g., honeypots, email spam traps, large networks). Your dataset would be relatively small and specific to your forum's issues.
* **Scalability:** A single forum's banned IP list, even a large one, might not be extensive enough to be a standalone product unless the specific nature of your banned IPs is *exceptionally* valuable (e.g., highly targeted, sophisticated attackers).
* **Reputation:** Monetizing banned user data, even IPs, might be viewed negatively by some users or in the security community if not handled transparently and ethically.

### Thoughts and Proposals:

1. **Market Niche:**
* **Focus on Specificity:** If your forum deals with a very niche topic that attracts specific types of spammers or attackers, then your IP list might be particularly valuable to other forums in that *exact* niche.
* **Context is King:** You MUST provide context. A buyer isn't just buying a list of numbers; they're buying a list of *known problematic IPs*. Describe *why* these IPs were banned (e.g., "known spammers," "account hijack attempts," "DDoS source IPs").

2. **Pricing Strategy:**
* **Tiered Pricing:** $10-$100 is a wide range. Consider tiers based on:
* **Size of the dataset:** Smaller, one-time purchase vs. larger, more comprehensive.
* **Update frequency:** One-time export vs. monthly/quarterly/yearly subscription.
* **Context/Metadata:** More detailed banning reasons or behavioral data might command a higher price.
* **Trial Offer:** Offer a small, free sample to demonstrate the quality and relevance of your data.

3. **Distribution and Marketing:**
* **Specialized Forums/Communities:** Market this in forums or communities for webmasters, forum administrators, and cybersecurity professionals.
* **B2B Focus:** Your market is likely other businesses or website owners, not individual consumers.
* **Clear Value Proposition:** Emphasize the benefit: "Proactively protect your forum from known spammers and malicious actors with our regularly updated banned IP list."

4. **Ethical & Legal Due Diligence:**
* **Review Your Terms of Service:** Does your forum's ToS state that you collect IP addresses and how they might be used or shared? You need to ensure you're compliant.
* **GDPR/CCPA/Local Laws:** Consult with legal counsel, or at least thoroughly research, the implications of selling this data, especially if your forum has users from regions with strict data privacy laws. An IP address, especially when combined with timestamps or other data, can sometimes be considered personal data. This is crucial.

**Overall Proposal:**

It's an interesting concept, but the success hinges on **value proposition, data quality, and addressing ethical/legal concerns.**

My main thought is that the **value of raw banned IP addresses alone is limited** unless they are accompanied by:

* **High-quality, recent data.**
* **Contextual information** about why they were banned.
* **Legal assurance** that selling them is permissible.

You might find more success by offering it as a **supplemental service** for existing anti-spam tools or as a niche product for highly specialized forums rather than a broad market commodity. The "Viking principle" of turning disadvantage into advantage is well applied here, but the practical execution requires careful consideration of data utility and legal compliance.
Follow up prompt to Bing Copilot and Bing Copilot Search:

Do you know the Norwegian term:

God dag mann økse skaft and how it relates to your last answer?

The phrase "Goddag mann, økseskaft!" (Good day, fellow axe handle) has become a common idiom for a non sequitur, not just in Norway but also the rest of Scandinavia ("Goddag, yxskaft!" in Swedish, "Goddag mand, økseskaft!" in Danish and "Hyvää päivää, kirvesvartta!" in Finnish).



Exercise for you.
1. Issue the prompt above and comment.
2. The main reason for getting your Ip banned is. It is obvious that the member had not read even the minimalistic forum rules. Is it a legal action to ban such an IP?
Post Reply